Women shouldn’t have to compete against men in order to play sports.
Yet that’s exactly what is happening increasingly across the country and around the world, as a growing number of male athletes who self-identify as women are being allowed to enter women’s competitions.
The so-called Equality Act would only worsen this trend. This piece of federal legislation, being pushed by House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., would create a civil right for male athletes to self-identify as females at any time, without any evidence of physical changes to their bodies.
It would spell “the end of women’s sports,” in the words of Duke University Law School Professor Doriane Lambelet Coleman, who testified against the bill at a recent House Judiciary Committee hearing.
But at that hearing, Sunu Chandy of the National Women’s Law
Center trivialized these concerns. She stated, “We do not create policy about
myths and stereotypes … There’s no research to support the claim that allowing
trans athletes to play on teams that fit their gender identity will create a
Yet such evidence does exist. There is plenty of empirical
evidence showing that replacing “sex” with “gender identity” as a criterion for
entry into athletic competition would eliminate opportunities for the athletic
abilities of large numbers of women to be properly recognized.
In the case of Mack
Beggs, a female wrestler who identifies as male, she was allowed to take
testosterone. That led three of her female competitors to forfeit the competition
out of fear of being injured.
As Coleman testified in the hearing, “So overwhelming is the advantage of testosterone that thousands of men and boys could defeat the female Olympic gold medalists in the 400 meters.”
She also wrote in the New York Times, “It doesn’t matter that there are 100 females and three males in a girls’ race if the three males win spots in the final or on the podium because they are males.”
Everyone has the right to compete in sports, but creating a
right to compete on the basis of gender identity won’t simply add a right. It
will eliminate the right of women and girls to compete against members of their
In 1972, Congress
passed Title IX of the 1972 Educational Amendments to the Civil Rights Act, which
ordered schools to create separate athletic teams for women. Congress didn’t simply
tell schools to let women compete for spots on men’s teams. That would have
been self-defeating, as only a few exceptional female athletes would win spots
due to men’s greater physical power, strength, and speed.
Yet despite ample scientific evidence of males
physical advantages over females, supporters of the Equality Act
like Yale University School of Law professor Kenji Yoshino insist that “trans
women have not broadly displaced or disadvantaged non-trans women or girls when
allowed to compete in accordance with their gender.”
But even without the Equality Act, women and girls are losing
titles, medals, and scholarship opportunities in states where gender identity has
already replaced sex. H.R. 5 would dramatically accelerate and expand these adverse impacts on females by requiring athletic programs to recognize
gender identity as a protected class in order to receive federal funding.
Here are 10 examples of male athletes identifying as women
in female sports. Under the Equality Act, we could only expect more of this.
- In track, male runner Nattaphon Wanyat edged out high school female athletes at the Alaska state track state championships.
- In softball, male player Pat (Patrick) Cordova-Goff took one of 15 spots on his California high school women’s varsity softball team.
- In basketball, a 50-year-old, 6’8”, 230-pound man, Robert (Gabrielle) Ludwig, led the Mission College women’s basketball team to a national championship with the most rebounds.
- In track and field, male high school runner “CeCe Telfer” won three titles in the NorthEast 10 Championships for women’s track, and received the Most Outstanding Track Athlete award.
- In Mixed Martial Arts, male fighter Fallon Fox shattered female fighter Tamikka Brents’ eye socket and gave her a concussion. Brents said she “never felt so overpowered in her life.”
- In football, male player Christina Ginther sued the Minnesota Independent Women’s Football League when they determined it was unsafe to let him play women. The league had changed its eligibility policy in 2012, requiring players to certify that they are and always have been female—but a jury awarded Ginther $20,000 for being “discriminated” against under state law, and he was placed on multiple women’s teams.
- In marathon running, male runner Aron Taylor won first place in his very first attempt in the Jacksonville Women’s Marathon.
- In cycling, male cyclist Jillian (Jonathan) Bearden took first place in the women’s division of the U.S. Peleton at El Tour de Tucson in 2016. Bearden plans to qualify for the U.S. Women’s Olympic cycling team for 2020.
- In roller derby, a 6’7”, 270-pound man, June Gloom, was featured on The Rollergirl Project—a blog showing different body types of roller derby skaters.
- In Connecticut’s state track and field championships, two male high school runners, Andraya Yearwood and Terry Miller, took first and second place in multiple events, beating out top high school girls from across the state. Connecticut subsequently named Yearwood Athlete of the Year.
In the last example, 16-year-old Selina
Soule described the
race as “demoralizing” because, when male athletes enter women and girls’
races, everyone knows who will win before the race begins. Even worse, her chances
of being seen by college scouts disappeared when Yearwood and Miller took top
spots at the state championships.
Soule said she chose to speak out so that no other girl
athlete would face the same disappointment. Hopefully, Congress will listen to
voices like hers before it’s too late.