Tzvi Struck, a resident of the Samaria community of Shilo, was sentenced on Monday to a year and a half in prison after he was convicted of beating an Arab on the outskirts of Shilo four years ago.
Struck’s indictment alleged that he, along with another man, beat a PA Arab shepherd and dragged him onto a tractor. The shepherd was injured and consequently lost consciousness, claims the indictment. Struck’s conviction had been announced in November.
In his ruling, Jerusalem District Court Judge Amnon Cohen expressed his shock at the severe bruises that were found on the body of the Arab boy. The judge ruled that the evidence presented about Struck’s character in his defense is inconsistent with his actions, and added that for this reason, a punishment that does not include imprisonment may not pass along the correct message about the severity of Struck’s actions. Struck was also ordered to compensate the Arab boy with a sum of fifty thousand shekels.
Struck denied the accusations against him all along and said they were false. He said that the police work was sloppy and that the testimonies by the Arabs were contradictory, a fact that Judge Cohen noted in his verdict despite having ruled against Struck. Struck also said that the Yesh Din, an extreme left-wing organization whose stated mission is “to oppose the continuing violation of Palestinian human rights in the Occupied Palestinian Territory” and which filed the charges against Struck, updated the various witnesses in the case on the contents of testimonies by other witnesses.
Struck’s mother is Orit Struck, who heads the Judea and Samaria Human Rights Organization. She responded to her son’s sentencing on Monday, telling Arutz Sheva that “Judge Amnon Cohen’s sentence gives victory to the false Arab witnesses who conduct a war against the Jewish farmers. The judge preferred to believe the main witness, who is a terrorist standing trial for throwing Molotov cocktails, over Tzviki Struck, a farmer with no previous criminal record, whom character witnesses noted is a delicate gentleman who is responsible and law-abiding.”
Orit Struck added that “the judge chose to ignore the fact that the complainant’s father is a Palestinian Authority policeman who brought all the prosecution’s witnesses and amazingly was also the one who sat in the interrogation room and served as their interpreter. Judge Cohen turned a farmer and father of 3 children into a scapegoat in the nationalist war conducted by Arabs against Jewish agriculture in Judea and Samaria.”
Source material can be found at this site.