Israel Advocacy on Campus – It’s Easier Than You Think

January 2, 2013 13:52 by

Aidan Fishman is a student of International Relations and Near and Middle Eastern Studies at the University of Toronto and the winner of HonestReporting’s inaugural Blankfeld Award for Quality Journalism.

For far too many people, any mention of the words “Israel” and “university campus” in close conjunction conjure up images of doom and gloom. University students are steadily growing hostile toward the Jewish State, and the anti-Israel Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) Movement is gaining credibility on campuses across the United States and Canada – or so we are led to believe.

In fact, the situation is not nearly so dire. There are many indications that the university anti-Israel movement is actually losing steam, due to both its inherent contradictions and the hard work of passionate Zionists on campus. Better yet, whether you’re a student, a parent or even a potential donor, standing up for Israel and for basic principles of equality and civility on campus is easier than you would expect.

In this piece, relying on both personal anecdotes and more formal North American studies, I’ll review three basic trends in the battle for Israel on our campuses.

1.    The University is not Universal

Paradoxically, the first key thing to remember about defending Israel on campus is that it’s not as significant as you might expect. Universities have long ceased to be useful barometers of what average citizens, even well-educated average citizens, believe, think or vote. Most students come to university to explore their intellectual passions or simply acquire the degree(s) necessary for their dream job, not to become politically active or fight for social justice.

Since the 1960?s at least, North American campuses have been reliable strongholds of the far-left. A quick glance at any electoral map makes this obvious; college towns in the U.S. often deliver the Democratic votes necessary to swing a municipality, a congressional district, or even a state, while Canadian ridings with heavy student populations plump reliably for the NDP.

For whatever reason, the “Palestinian cause” has been the pet issue of the global far-left for decades now, giving anti-Israel activists a distinctive edge on campus as compared to the rest of the electorate. However, there’s nothing “progressive” about the anti-Semitism of Hamas or Hezbollah, or the suicide bombings that necessitated Israel’s security barrier. But the lack of a level playing field that favors anti-Israel forces is simply a fact of life that pro-Israel activists must accept.

This left-leaning bias has two key implications. Firstly, most student governments lean far to the left, even more so than the average student population. This renders them hostile to pro-Israel forces, who are generally wise to assume that their own elected representatives are working against them.

In Case You Missed It:  HERE WE GO: Thousands of Israeli Troops Storm into Gaza as “Rolling Start” to Ground Invasion Reportedly Begins to Wipe Out Hamas (VIDEO)

However, there is a more positive corollary to this unfortunate state of affairs. Since student governments are institutionally left-wing, and often feature extremely low turnout rates and even rigged elections, anti-Israel declarations on their behalf are essentially meaningless. For example, the University of Toronto’s Graduate Students Union recently passed a motion demanding that the administration divest from firms that support “Israeli war crimes”. The motion allegedly passed with “97% percent of students in favour” – greatly aided by the fact that the union never notified its members of the divisive resolution, meaning that no pro-Israel students even bothered to attend the union’s typically banal Annual General Meeting!

Clearly, this “great victory” for BDS does not truly reflect the views of U of T graduate students, let alone the student body as a whole. Only a few pro-Israel and anti-Israel partisans are aware that it occurred; evidently, the BDS ideological clique isn’t doing much to reach out to unaffiliated students.

The second critical implication of universities’ leftist tilt is the centrality of tailoring our pro-Israel message for this student audience. Most university students don’t give a fig that Jerusalem is the religious capital of the Jewish people, mentioned hundreds of times in the Bible – in fact, many would dismiss Israel altogether merely because one of its advocates made a religious argument. It is typically far more productive to highlight its role in advancing cellphone technology, its pioneering techniques of water conservation, and its relatively robust record on gay rights, women’s equality and ethno-religious minorities that puts its rivals to shame. Campus advocates need to reach students on their level, appealing to factors present in their everyday lives or favorable to them politically.

2.    Every Campus is Different

Of course, there is an important caveat to all this talk of an inherently hostile university atmosphere – every campus is unique, and each demands a slightly different approach to Israel advocacy.

Take the late Jerry Falwell’s Liberty University in Lynchburg, Virginia, for example. There, it’s fair to assume that the vast majority of students are already friends of the Jewish State; thus, local friends of Israel would spend their time galvanizing the pro-Israel community and encouraging them to donate to Zionist organizations and remember Israel at the ballot box, utilizing the same biblical arguments that are anathema to students at most Western universities.

Finer nuances between relatively similar campuses also effect our responses to anti-Israel activity. A few years ago, local anti-Israel activists erected an ersatz Israeli checkpoint outside a major student center of Queen’s University in Kingston, Ontario. They then demanded students provide them with their student ID’s before entering the building seeking to emulate the “humiliation” inflicted upon West Bank Palestinians. Seeing that this tactic was effective, pro-Israel students at Queen’s hit back in ingenious fashion, popping balloons and throwing confetti at “the checkpoint” to simulate a Palestinian terrorist attack, demonstrating the sad necessity of Israeli security measures.

In Case You Missed It:  I saw her naked...

By contrast, when the local chapter of anti-Israel fanatics unveiled the same strategy outside Robarts Library at the University of Toronto, angry students simply pushed right past them, unwilling to waste their time on such chicanery.

Unfortunately, these variations between campuses tend to reduce the efficacy of continent-wide initiatives sponsored by groups like Hillel and B’nai B’rith. A great example of this phenomenon is the “Size Doesn’t Matter” campaign, which tries to ameliorate Israel’s image on campus by highlighting the hip and “sexy” side of the Jewish State. While it has proved to be a roaring success at more party-oriented Canadian universities such as Western University and the University of British Columbia, it has been less successful at academic hot spots like the University of Toronto. In Canada’s largest city, students are more likely to back Israel after hearing a well-reasoned refutation of bogus anti-Israel claims than upon receiving a free t-shirt or condom.

Growing frustration with cookie-cutter national campaigns and a desire for a grassroots, student-led Zionist movement has spawned an increasing number of independent, autonomous pro-Israel student groups on campuses across North America. While refusing to take orders from a central organization, these clubs often work hand-in-hand with Hillel to promote Israel, relying on their familiarity with the student body and ability to say and do what they want without waiting for orders from abroad. I expect this sophisticated form of micro-targeting to become the face of university Israel advocacy over the next decade, replicating similar developments in the American political arena.

3.    It’s Easy to Lend a Hand

Perhaps the best news about Israel advocacy on campus is that it’s easy to get involved, regardless of your academic status or income level. On most campuses, there is a small core of dedicated Israel activists, who regularly skip class, stay up late, and even postpone vacations in order to better combat anti-Israel demonstrations. Meanwhile, the university’s larger Jewish student population cheers them on from the sidelines, but declines their invitations to get involved.

This ought to change, for a variety of reasons. Obviously, Israel advocacy becomes increasingly effective as more and more students lend a hand. The effect is exponential, because each passionate Zionist who openly joins the cause will have tens or even hundreds of non-Jewish, non-committed friends on campus, who might receive their first serious exposure to the problems plaguing the Middle East via their friend’s advocacy.

In Case You Missed It:  Senator Rand Paul Says Criticism of Ongoing Funding for Ukraine is a ‘Growing Movement’ in Washington

But most Jewish students don’t become heavily involved in pro-Israel activity, which leads us to the heart of the problem. Anti-Israel forces on campus have failed miserably in achieving their stated goals: despite years of campaigning, no North American university has actually divested from Israel or companies that do business with it, and anecdotal evidence suggests that most non-committed students are frankly repelled by the gruesome, over-the-top verbal attacks staged against the Jewish State and its friends on campus.

As a practical matter, the BDS Movement and its fellow travelers have no effect whatsoever on the Middle East or domestic politics – but they are causing damage here, at home. On Canadian campuses where anti-Israel activity is most virulent and commonplace, Jewish students, even those not formally involved with Zionist clubs, become frightened and demoralized. Friends have told me that they feel unsafe wearing kippot or Star of David necklaces at York and Concordia Universities, for fear of anti-Semitic or anti-Zionist assault and persecution.

In truth, Israel advocacy on North American campuses is less about fighting for Israel than fighting for the right of Jewish and Zionist students to speak freely on campus, without being ashamed of their identity or beliefs.

Everyone can pitch in for this all-important struggle. Jewish students who wish to avoid the limelight can still contribute, whether by designing posters off-campus, writing pamphlets, or soliciting donations. Parents can help by encouraging their sons and daughters to seek out pro-Israel groups when they arrive on campus.

North American Jews are accustomed to fielding hundreds of financial requests from community organizations each year. While donating to your local Hillel branch is always a great option, more donors should consider lending money to the aforementioned grassroots, campus-specific pro-Israel organizations. These start-ups typically require far less money – as little as fifty or a hundred dollars can fund their activities for an entire semester. Better yet, these small clubs are extremely transparent, lacking the costly but necessary bureaucracy of a national organization.


Israel advocates are winning the battle on campus, rendering the melodramatic antics of anti-Zionist instigators irrelevant with confident displays of logic and poise. In my three years on campus, I’ve seen the BDS Movement tangibly lose steam year after year.

But the battle is not yet won. If we are to continue the struggle, and return the genie of campus anti-Israel sentiment to its bottle, we need the help of people like you.

Source material can be found at this site.

Posted in Israel, Terrorism and tagged , , , , , , .